Frankenstein Recasting: Andrew Garfield Replaced by Jacob Elordi
How did Jacob Elordi perform as The Creature? Fans of Guillermo del Toro, including myself, were thrilled when news broke about the Oscar-winning director's adaptation of Frankenstein, a project he had envisioned for nearly two decades. Del Toro is known for his compassionate portrayal of monsters, evident in films like Pan’s Labyrinth and The Shape of Water.
Despite my excitement for the film, one production change initially dampened my enthusiasm. The movie, released on Netflix on November 7, 2025, revealed that Andrew Garfield had dropped out due to scheduling conflicts, and Jacob Elordi stepped in as the lead.
Thoughts on the Casting Change
Elordi is a talented actor, having delivered a chilling performance in Euphoria and impressed as Elvis Presley in Priscilla. However, Andrew Garfield remains one of my all-time favorite actors, so the change sparked mixed feelings.
"Andrew Garfield had dropped out of the movie due to ‘scheduling conflicts,’ and Jacob Elordi would be taking over."
After watching the film, I have gathered my thoughts on Elordi's interpretation of the iconic Creature and the overall impact of this casting shift.
Guillermo del Toro's sensitive approach to monsters sets a compelling tone for this adaptation, making the casting choice especially significant for fans and newcomers alike.
Summary
This recasting initially disturbed my anticipation, but Jacob Elordi’s performance in del Toro’s Frankenstein offers a fresh and haunting interpretation that grows on the viewer.
Author’s takeaway: Changes in casting can challenge expectations, yet can also bring new depth to beloved characters when handled by skilled actors under visionary direction.